What’s the Matter with My Matter Compatible Smart Plug?

For the past few years, I’ve been using an Amazon Smart Plug to automate the on/off schedule for one of our lamps at home. It’s been working just fine… completely straight forward. So, I decided to buy another smart plug for a second lamp.

It’s been a while since I’ve shopped for smart plugs. And while there are multiple brands in this field, I thought I’d stick with an Amazon product. I’ve been controlling the one smart plug with the Alexa app on my iPhone. So, I felt it made sense to stay in the same ecosystem.

But when I took a look, Amazon had seemingly expanded its lineup:

  • Amazon Smart Plug – This is the one I had bought before.
    $24.99
  • Amazons Basics Smart Plug
    $10.99
  • Amazon Basics Smart Plug, Matter Compatible
    $8.98

Does It Matter?

Admittedly, I didn’t spend a lot of time researching the differences between these three options. I shopped price and quickly focused on the Matter Compatible model. (I haven’t previously used a Matter device.)

Matter is an open smart home standard that helps smart devices from different brands work together. It’s a bridge that solves for brand/tech fragmentation.

But as I intended to stick to the Amazon/Alexa ecosystem, I figured it was just a feature that I wouldn’t use. And so, I decided to save a couple bucks by purchasing this model.

Click.

But that’s where my savings ended.

Failure to Activate, No Matter What

I didn’t fully understand that this Amazon Basics Matter Compatible Smart Plug required a more complex activation process, specifically because of the Matter factor.

First, I needed a ‘hub’ to pair it into… another Alexa device like an Echo speaker. Fortunately, I had an Echo Dot I use to crank tunes in our basement. So, I used that.

Then, I was prompted to complete additional steps, I but quickly got stuck. (I tried numerous times.)

Next, I found the online instructions to see if I had missed something. I even asked Claude and Gemini for help.

Nothing was working.

What’s the Matter?

I did a little more online research and realized that lots of people were having similar problems with this Matter Compatible smart plug. I went back to Amazon and reviewed my purchase. I noticed Amazon posted a warning message towards the bottom that stated lots of buyers had returned this item due to compatibility problems.

Huh.

Okay. My bad. I didn’t do my homework. Not a terrible mistake for nine bucks. Plus, I could easily return this misbehaving smart plug.

I started to box it up, but I thought again about Matter’s cross platform functionality.

What about using this smart plug via Apple’s Home app?

Welcome Home!

I tried this set up option almost as a lark. I didn’t look up any instructions. I just tapped on my iPhone’s Apple Home app to see what it would offer me.

Then, the app quickly and intuitively enabled me to add the smart plug. So easy. So… matter of fact.

Lamp automated. Project completed.

I was in shock. This took me literally 3 minutes to figure out and execute. It was the way it was supposed to be. (Thank you, Apple!)

The only downside was this second Amazon smart plug now lived in my Apple Home app and not my Amazon Alexa app. That’s not perfect and goes against the idea of keeping everything under one roof.

However, for my planned use, it’s mostly set and forget. So, that’s not a big deal.

How Many Hours Does It Take to Activate a Smart Plug?

As I reflect on my frustrating experience, it’s ironic that the Matter factor seemingly prevented me from pairing my new Amazon Basics Smart Plug to my Alexa app. That should be easy!

But the Matter option allowed me to easily jump to the Apple platform (which wasn’t my plan).

Now, I’m sure there’s an explanation for my failed Alexa operation. I expect an engineer would say it’s my fault. I did something wrong. (And I’m sure I did.)

But it doesn’t matter. This user couldn’t get it done. (And that’s all that matters.)

And then then the Matter factor helped me with a workaround… the way it was designed to. (Yay, Matter!)

Mind Over Matter

So what did I learn here?

  • Sometimes tech works. Sometimes it doesn’t.
  • Do your research before you buy.
  • Don’t always choose the least expensive option.
  • Be flexible and look for the workaround.

While my Matter Compatible smart plug setup experience was not a particularly good one, the technology did ultimately solve my problem. And what matters most… I now understand Matter’s potential.

As a matter of fact, I believe I will try it again in the future.

It’s just a matter of time.